Summarize:

Unless it's specified in the script that your character does something like a smoky eye, keep dramatic makeup off the stage. Dramatic colors, especially around the eyes, will look unnatural on the stage. Stick to eyeshadow colors that match your natural skin tone. Get as many waterproof brands of makeup as you can. Waterproof makeup will hold up better as you sweat on stage, preventing your makeup from smearing. You will also not waste as much time reapplying makeup. You may get concerned if your makeup ends up looking overdone. This is normal for stage makeup, so do not tone down your look. People need to be able to see you under the lights and from a distance. Your makeup will look a little dramatic, but that's okay.
Avoid dramatic colors. Make sure all your makeup is waterproof. Don't worry if your makeup looks overdone.